Skip to main content

Table 1 Summarized results for the different PLLs and the proposed PLL

From: DC offset rejection in a frequency-fixed second-order generalized integrator-based phase-locked loop for single-phase grid-connected applications

Case study

Proposed FFSOGI-PLL

ESOGI-PLL

Modified SOGI-PLL

mEPLL

20° phase jump

    

2% phase settling time (ms)

41.60

92.90

86.30

64.50

Phase overshoot (%)

40.3835

49.81

54.01

49.84

Peak frequency (Hz)

52.81

53.33

52.74

53.26

20° phase jump and 0.15 pu DC offset

    

2% phase settling time (ms)

42.40

95.30

89.10

71.30

Phase overshoot (%)

45.89

50.41

59.78

51.77

Peak frequency (Hz)

53.40

53.80

53.24

54.31

3 Hz frequency jump

    

2% frequency settling time (ms)

47.80

79.40

74.00

64.7

Frequency overshoot (%)

0.26

1.10

0.44

0.65

Peak phase error (°)

6.65

7.85

9.71

6.31

Peak frequency (Hz)

53.10

53.58

53.23

53.34

3 Hz frequency jump and 0.15 pu DC offset

    

2% frequency settling time (ms)

48.20

78.30

69.90

71.10

Frequency overshoot (%)

0.69

2.39

0.72

2.05

Peak phase error (°)

14.91

16.55

19.67

18.23

Peak frequency (Hz)

53.37

54.27

53.38

54.09

0.15 pu DC offset only

    

2% phase settling time (ms)

43.60

74.70

50.10

47.50

Absolute peak phase error (°)

8.43

8.84

9.87

11.83

Peak frequency deviation (Hz)

1.09

1.29

1.12

1.81

Amplitude reduced by 0.2 pu and 0.15 pu DC offset

    

2% phase settling time (ms)

40.30

83.40

66.60

82.50

Peak phase error (°)

5.19

7.23

15.68

21.99

Peak frequency deviation (Hz)

0.79

1.22

1.82

3.70