Skip to main content

Table 6 Cases simulated to test relay logic for unknown data

From: A novel out of step relaying algorithm based on wavelet transform and a deep learning machine model

Case No

Type of event

Power swing produced due to:

The output of the proposed relay

Swing center arises at HV of GTU of G2

1

Unstable power swing

LLLG fault (Tfault > Tcr)

[1 0 0]

2

Stable power swing

LLLG fault (Tfault < Tcr)

[0 1 0]

3

Three-phase faults

Not applicable

[0 0 1]

4

Stable power swing

Sudden load changes

[0 1 0]

5

Unstable power swing

Sudden load changes

[1 0 0]

6

Unstable power swing

LG fault (Tfault > Tcr)

[1 0 0]

7

Stable power swing

LG fault (Tfault < Tcr)

[0 1 0]

Swing center arises at HV of GTU of G3

8

Unstable power swing

LLLG fault (Tfault > Tcr)

[1 0 0]

9

Stable power swing

LLLG fault (Tfault < Tcr)

[0 1 0]

10

Three-phase faults

Not applicable

[0 0 1]

11

Stable power swing

Sudden load changes

[0 1 0]

12

Unstable power swing

Sudden load changes

[1 0 0]

13

Unstable power swing

LG fault (Tfault > Tcr)

[1 0 0]

14

Stable power swing

LG fault (Tfault < Tcr)

[0 1 0]

Renewable integration

15

Unstable power swing

50% level of integration

[1 0 0]

16

Stable power swing

7% level of integration

[0 1 0]

17

Three-phase faults

Not applicable

[0 0 1]

Swing center arises at the middle of the TL-2

18

Unstable power swing

LLLG fault (Tfault > Tcr)

[1 0 0]

19

Stable power swing

LLLG fault (Tfault < Tcr)

[0 1 0]

20

Three-phase faults

Not applicable

[0 0 1]

  1. Note: Tfault = fault clearing time; Tcr = Critical clearing time; LLLG = triple line to ground; LG = line to ground; TL-2 = Transmission line-2