Skip to main content

Table 3 Simulation results for test system 3

From: Review on application and comparison of metaheuristic techniques to multi-area economic dispatch problem

Power (MW)

DE

SA

EP

RCGA

Power (MW)

DE

SA

EP

RCGA

Ρ 1,1

111.5448

110.9120

107.6644

95.7552

Ρ 3,4

523.4073

523.3366

525.7752

518.1120

Ρ 1,2

111.7092

111.8740

112.0673

88.5828

Ρ 3,5

523.7703

525.5247

531.2092

538.1994

Ρ 1,3

98.2429

110.2589

91.8132

97.6063

Ρ 3,6

523.5424

523.2794

513.5659

527.4775

Ρ 1,4

179.8834

179.7351

175.3171

126.4966

Ρ 3,7

10.1621

10.0002

11.3612

24.4133

Ρ 1,5

95.9500

88.8739

92.4242

71.0127

Ρ 3,8

10.1326

10.0006

10.0000

28.9856

Ρ 1,6

139.3533

68.0000

112.5634

116.3866

Ρ 3,9

10.6366

10.0006

10.0000

28.8571

Ρ 1,7

259.3395

184.9322

257.5370

244.5857

Ρ 3,10

88.1189

93.2065

78.3523

87.9016

Ρ 1,8

285.3569

285.0432

297.3619

210.6920

Ρ 4,1

161.2220

190.0000

162.4480

159.7482

Ρ 1,9

284.9627

284.6015

285.2035

236.1685

Ρ 4,2

189.5668

189.9990

166.3508

153.6255

Ρ 1,10

130.2217

130.0008

134.5862

130.1286

Ρ 4,3

189.9240

159.7546

190.0000

160.4706

Ρ 2,1

243.6005

168.6194

162.4313

367.4862

Ρ 4,4

165.6621

165.6736

178.4541

169.9359

Ρ 2,2

95.3890

318.3986

217.8387

297.9501

Ρ 4,5

165.4321

164.8248

168.0752

168.5220

Ρ 2,3

214.5171

304.5197

125.0000

394.9246

Ρ 4,6

164.9868

196.1794

174.4529

172.2638

Ρ 2,4

394.0808

394.2792

384.0187

370.3473

Ρ 4,7

109.8137

89.1143

77.3875

91.2423

Ρ 2,5

394.2481

469.0618

397.6902

455.7123

Ρ 4,8

109.7935

89.1147

90.1059

86.4778

Ρ 2,6

394.4360

304.5195

407.4993

393.9673

Ρ 4,9

90.1543

104.7206

109.5654

88.3627

Ρ 2,7

489.9552

489.2801

500.0000

424.1994

Ρ 4,10

459.1140

458.7992

549.0335

279.2691

Ρ 2,8

488.8885

489.2803

480.8874

484.5498

Τ 12

172.0652

192.6532

200

−71.7855

Ρ 2,9

511.4713

511.2790

524.8487

528.4148

Τ 31

−36.3060

160.6028

17.5885

161.9336

Ρ 2,10

511.4125

511.2805

499.7857

511.3403

Τ 32

191.1128

−46.9736

200

95.2833

Ρ 3,1

523.2896

524.8208

523.4522

525.4497

Τ 41

86.8070

52.8188

90.8733

−76.1340

Ρ 3,2

523.2950

523.2802

526.5051

510.7391

Τ 42

98.8231

93.8021

100

−52.3900

Ρ 3,3

523.4129

433.6204

537.3675

533.6399

Τ 43

45.0391

86.5590

100

83.4418

Total cost ($/h)

121794.8

123337.1

123591.9

128046.5

CPU time (second)

134.8125

29.2813

144.5000

160.5313